Murder and Manslaughter
Our criminal law experience is your strongest defence.
Book your consultation
Call us now on (02) 9158 8777 or fill out our online enquiry form for a free, confidential first consultation.
Why Choose Us?
Being charged with murder or manslaughter is one of the most serious situations a person can face in the New South Wales criminal justice system. These charges carry the heaviest penalties available under NSW law, and the court process can be lengthy, complex, and stressful for the accused and their family. If you or someone close to you has been charged, getting proper legal advice early makes a real difference to how the matter is handled and the outcome that follows.
Understanding Murder and Manslaughter Charges in NSW
Homicide offences in New South Wales are governed by the Crimes Act 1900 (NSW) together with principles built up by the courts over many years, known as common law. These principles guide how the legislation is applied to individual cases based on precedent set in earlier decisions.
Both murder and manslaughter are prosecuted on behalf of the state by the Office of the Director of Public Prosecutions. Every accused person is presumed innocent, and the burden sits with the prosecution to establish guilt beyond a reasonable doubt. Where a person enters a guilty plea at the first reasonable opportunity, the court may reduce the sentence by up to 25 per cent.
It is common for police to lay charges of both murder and manslaughter together. This approach gives the court an alternative finding if the evidence does not support a murder conviction but does establish manslaughter. Even without a separate manslaughter charge being laid, a jury may still return a manslaughter verdict as an alternative to acquittal.
What Counts as Murder
Under the Crimes Act, a person commits murder where their act or failure to act causes death and is accompanied by one of the following:
- Reckless indifference to human life, meaning the person foresaw that death was a probable consequence of their conduct and proceeded regardless
- An intention to kill or cause grievous bodily harm to another person
- The act occurred while committing, attempting to commit, or immediately following a crime punishable by 25 years or life imprisonment
Murder attracts a maximum penalty of life imprisonment, with a standard non-parole period of 20 years where a life sentence is not imposed. Where the victim was a police officer killed in connection with their duties, a life sentence becomes mandatory, with a 25-year non-parole period.
Constructive Murder
Also called felony murder, this applies where a death results during or straight after a serious offence, regardless of whether the accused intended to kill or harm anyone. The prosecution must show that a voluntary act or omission occurred and that it took place during or immediately following the commission of a serious crime.
Attempted Murder and Conspiracy
The law recognises several forms of attempted murder, covering acts intended to kill through poisoning, wounding, arson, sabotage of transport infrastructure, and other violent means, even where no injury actually results. Each carries a maximum penalty of 25 years’ imprisonment, with a 10-year standard non-parole period.
Conspiring or agreeing with another person to commit murder is treated equally seriously. This applies regardless of whether the intended victim resides in Australia or overseas, and regardless of their citizenship. The maximum penalty mirrors that for attempted murder.
Killing of a Child by Its Mother
The law sets out separate offences dealing with the death of a newborn at the hands of its mother, including causing the child’s death during or after birth, and concealing the birth of a child who has died. Where the mother’s state of mind was affected by the physical or psychological effects of childbirth or breastfeeding, the offence of infanticide may apply instead of murder, and is treated in the same way as manslaughter.
Assault Causing Death and Supply of Drugs Causing Death
A person can be found guilty of assault causing death where an unlawful, unauthorised assault results in another person’s death, even indirectly, such as from a fall following the assault. This carries a 20-year maximum penalty, rising to 25 years where the accused was an adult and intoxicated at the time. A related offence applies where a person supplies a prohibited drug for payment or gain, and the person who takes it dies as a result, also carrying a maximum 20-year sentence.
Manslaughter
Manslaughter covers every unlawful killing that does not meet the definition of murder and carries a maximum penalty of 25 years’ imprisonment. Courts recognise two broad categories.
Voluntary manslaughter arises where the elements of murder are technically present, but factors such as provocation or a substantial impairment of the mind reduce the offender’s culpability.
Involuntary manslaughter is split further into manslaughter by unlawful and dangerous act, and manslaughter by criminal negligence. The former requires a voluntary act that was both unlawful and dangerous, judged against whether a reasonable person in the accused’s position would have recognised the risk of serious injury or death. The latter applies where a person owing a duty of care, such as a parent, employer, doctor or driver, fails so significantly to meet the expected standard of care that death results.
Available Legal Defences
Several defences and partial defences may reduce a murder charge to manslaughter or result in acquittal altogether. Extreme provocation applies where the deceased’s conduct amounted to a serious indictable offence that caused the accused to lose self-control in a manner that an ordinary person might also have lost control. Substantial impairment by abnormality of mind may apply where a diagnosed condition affected the accused’s capacity to reason or exercise self-control, though this defence must be proven by the accused and typically requires expert psychiatric evidence. Self-defence remains available where force was used to protect oneself or another, though excessive force resulting in death will usually reduce the charge to manslaughter rather than lead to a full acquittal.
Speak With Our Team
If you or a family member has been charged with murder, manslaughter, or a related offence, contact Best Criminal Lawyers Sydney for an initial consultation at our Sydney office. Every case turns on its own facts, and early legal advice can shape the outcome significantly.
Disclaimer: This content is general legal information only and does not constitute legal advice. Speak with one of our solicitors about your specific circumstances. Penalties referred to are maximum penalties, and outcomes are determined by the court on a case-by-case basis.